Have you ever made a snap judgment only to find out later you were way off?
That’s not just human nature. It’s apparently a predictable mental pattern called the Ladder of Inference. It’s quietly undermining your team’s decisions, your mentees’ confidence, and your own ability to lead with clarity.
Understanding this concept will give you one of the most powerful tools to avoid unnecessary conflict, flawed decisions, and toxic beliefs.
What Is the Ladder of Inference?
Developed by Harvard professor Chris Argyris and later popularized in The Fifth Discipline by Peter Senge, the Ladder of Inference explains how people move (often unconsciously) from observing something to taking action, through a series of mental leaps.
The problem? Each leap can move us further from truth and deeper into assumption-driven behavior.
The Rungs of the Ladder
Let’s break it down, from the ground up:
1. Observable Data
The raw facts—what was actually said or done.
Your colleague walked past you in the hallway without saying hello.
2. Selected Data
We subconsciously filter what we notice based on past experiences or biases.
You focus on their silence, not the fact they were on their phone.
3. Interpreted Meaning
We assign personal meaning based on our own lens.
“They’re ignoring me.”
4. Assumptions
We fill in gaps with beliefs we assume to be true.
“They must be upset with me.”
5. Conclusions
We mentally “close the case.”
“I’ve done something wrong.”
6. Beliefs
These conclusions reinforce how we see the world or others.
“I can’t trust them, they clearly have it out for me.”
7. Actions
We act based on the belief—not the original facts.
You avoid them for the rest of the week. Communication breaks down.
Why This Matters in Mentorship
This is where mentorship becomes critical. Most people climb this ladder every day and they don’t realize it. As a mentor, you can teach others how to:
- Slow down their thinking
- Separate fact from assumption
- Communicate with clarity
- Disarm their own bias before it becomes a belief
How to Use This in a Mentoring Conversation
When someone comes to you frustrated, offended, or convinced of something that feels reactionary…pause and walk them down the ladder:
Ask:
- What actually happened?
- What did you notice or focus on?
- What did you make that mean?
- What assumptions are you making?
- What conclusion have you drawn?
- What action are you thinking about taking?
- What else could be true?
This is especially effective when coaching people through:
- Interpersonal conflict
- Leadership missteps
- Feedback interpretation
- Emotional overreaction
- First-time manager dilemmas
Case Example: The Silent Supervisor
A mentee once told me, “My manager hates me. She walks right by my desk without saying a word.”
We unpacked it using the ladder:
- Fact: She walked by without talking.
- Interpretation: You expected acknowledgment.
- Assumption: She’s mad at you.
- Alternative truth: She just came out of a tense meeting and was in her head.
They later discovered the supervisor had received tough news and appreciated space. That one moment could have created distance, bitterness, and disengagement but, pausing to walk the ladder diffused it instantly.
A Mentor’s Role
As mentors, we don’t just teach what to think, we help others learn how to think. The Ladder of Inference is a guide to:
- Clearer decisions
- Stronger relationships
- Wiser leadership
It also models the kind of self-reflection leaders need if they want to grow beyond reaction and into influence.
One Question That Changes Everything:
“Are you responding to facts—or to the story you’ve told yourself?”
deliberatedevelopment.org 